Fake dating the grumpy hockey player who's always topped her naughty list? What could go wrong?All Natalie D'Amore wants for Christmas is for her fake relationship with best friend Caden to turn real. But when Caden breaks his leg, and she needs someone with his face, she's stuck with his infuriating twin brother-Cole Sinclair. Broody, sharp-tongued, and hotter than sin, Cole's the last person she wants to take home to Maine to meet her family.Trapped en route in a rundown motel with one bed and a broken heater, feelings start to thaw and Natalie's holiday plans go sideways fast. Under the watchful eye of her relationship-obsessed parents, Cole is flirty, sweet, and a little too convincing.Cole has spent years quietly burning for Natalie while she's carried a torch for his brother-but now that her heart is finally opening, he's determined to show her they could have the kind of love that is fated by the stars.Between cookie disasters, tree-lighting ceremonies, and stolen kisses on a frozen pond a spellbinding connection strengthens between the two and pretending starts to feel a lot like the real thing. Soon, Natalie's second-guessing if she put Cole on the right list-or if this hockey player with a secret heart of gold deserves the top spot on her wish list instead.